Big-name games stay popular for years, which means there are often several editions and platform versions on sale at once. Buying the wrong one is easy: a PS4 disc for a console with no drive, or an older edition when an upgraded version exists. This guide explains what each of these three games offers and which version to look for on your console.
Before you buy: match the edition to your console
- No disc drive? The PS5 Digital Edition and Xbox Series S can’t play physical copies.
- Newer console? Check whether a native version exists (as with GTA V) or whether you’d be playing an older version through backward compatibility (as with Red Dead Redemption 2).
- Playing online? Console online play usually needs a paid subscription.
How we checked
Sources and limits (checked 28 October 2026)
- Edition contents and online requirements come from the PlayStation Store and Xbox Store pages.
- Platform versions and backward compatibility come from Rockstar’s announcements, as reported by Game Informer and GameSpot.
- Minecraft’s rating and cross-play information come from minecraft.net.
- We have not played these games for this guide. Star ratings, review counts, review scores and “low return rate” claims in older versions of this article could not be sourced and have been removed.
The games compared
| Game | Best for | Current-gen version | Online | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grand Theft Auto V | Open-world action plus a large online mode | Native PS5 and Xbox Series X|S versions | GTA Online; PS Plus required on PlayStation | Mature |
| Minecraft | Building and survival, solo or with friends | Bedrock Edition, cross-play across consoles | Online multiplayer needs a subscription | ESRB Everyone 10+ |
| Red Dead Redemption 2 | A long, story-led western | PS4 and Xbox One versions, playable on PS5 and Series X|S via backward compatibility | Red Dead Online | Mature |
1. Grand Theft Auto V
Strengths: a full single-player story plus GTA Online in one purchase. The Starter Pack adds GTA Online properties, vehicles and in-game cash.
Trade-offs: rated for mature players. The Starter Pack content is for GTA Online only, not the story. Check the listing’s platform carefully, because several editions are sold at once.
2. Minecraft
Strengths: friends on different consoles can play in the same worlds. It suits short sessions or long building projects.
Trade-offs: online multiplayer on consoles needs a paid subscription, and cross-play needs a Microsoft account sign-in.
3. Red Dead Redemption 2
Strengths: a long single-player story set in a large open world, plus Red Dead Online.
Trade-offs: rated for mature players. There’s no native PS5 or Series X|S version, so you’re playing the older version on newer hardware. It also needs a lot of storage space.
Frequently asked questions
Which version of GTA V should I buy for a PS5 or Xbox Series X|S?
Rockstar released separate PS5 and Xbox Series X|S versions in 2022, with upgraded graphics modes. The Premium Edition sold on PS4 and Xbox One includes the story, GTA Online and the Criminal Enterprise Starter Pack, and older versions can run on newer consoles through backward compatibility. Check the platform on the listing.
Is there a PS5 version of Red Dead Redemption 2?
Not a native one. Rockstar made the PS4 and Xbox One versions playable on PS5 and Xbox Series X|S through backward compatibility.
Can I play a PS4 or Xbox One disc on a PS5 Digital Edition or Xbox Series S?
No. Those consoles have no disc drive, so physical copies won’t work. Rockstar noted this when it confirmed backward compatibility for its games.
Do I need a subscription to play these games online?
On consoles, usually yes. PlayStation lists PS Plus as required for GTA Online, and Minecraft notes that online multiplayer needs a subscription sold separately. Story modes and single-player worlds don’t need one.
Are these games suitable for younger players?
Minecraft is rated Everyone 10+ by the ESRB. GTA V and Red Dead Redemption 2 are rated for mature players, so check your region’s rating on the box or store page.
More console guides
Sources
- PlayStation Store: Grand Theft Auto V Premium Edition
- Xbox Store: Grand Theft Auto V Premium Edition
- Game Informer: GTA V and GTA Online come to PS5 and Xbox Series X|S
- GameSpot: GTA 5 and Red Dead Redemption 2 PS5 and Xbox Series X compatibility
- Gameluster: Rockstar’s backward compatibility notes (disc-free consoles)
- GodisaGeek: Red Dead Redemption 2 install sizes
- TweakTown: Red Dead Redemption 2 ships on two discs
- Minecraft: About Minecraft (editions, cross-play and rating)
